Cognitive Dissonance on Crack

Cognitive dissonance is a concept used to describe the feeling of discomfort that results from holding two conflicting beliefs. In a state of dissonance, people may feel surprise, dread, guilt, anger, or embarrassment and are thus motivated to reduce the dissonance by either changing their thoughts or changing their actions in order to create consistency. Wikipedia has a diagram, but I’m just going to give you some examples from my own life that will be even better than a diagram.

The first way I used cognitive dissonance theory was around my body image. I highly recommend this for all women, especially those who spent their teen years bent over a toilet bowl. (Where the fuck’s my overshare minion?!)

Anyway, I  decided that walking around thinking I was fat was causing me too much discomfort: both in my head and in the way my pants fit. Now, I could have done a couple of different things. I could have reduced my calorie intake, increased my exercise level and desperately tried to lose weight like I’d done a gagillion other times in my life. Or, I could have just stopped thinking I was fat and bought pants that fit me better.

Okay, I hope you’re sitting down, because the next paragraph is where cognitive dissonance gets fun!

I opted for plan B: stop thinking I’m fat and get bigger pants. And you know what happened? First of all, my head was calm and content. I had eliminated the dissonance. And…I ended up losing weight. Naturally! Without even trying! Hurry! Give me another thought to put an exclamation point after!

Isn’t that amazing? When I relaxed my mind, when I stopped trying so hard and simply used acceptance of my current state, the end result was even better than if I’d tried really, really hard to change. But, and this is cool, even if I hadn’t lost any weight after I’d started accepting my body, it would not have mattered, because I’d already changed my thinking and was happy exactly the way I was. And my pants fit.

I’ve used the concept of cognitive dissonance and acceptance as a means to create peace, which has often resulted in change, many times in my life. But the reason I’m writing about it today is because there’s this guy named Shawn Achor, who works at a college in Cambridge. The one near Boston. He states that if  every day we say three things we are grateful for, journal, exercise, meditate and perform random acts of kindness, that we can increase our positive thinking and that this in turn increases productivity and creativity.

Think of that! Positive thinking increases productivity. Not pushing ourselves to the point of pain, but positive thinking. It’s awesome!

I would argue that this positive thinking Shawn talks about is very similar to the kind of state that is produced when we stop beating ourselves up and start just accepting where we’re at in an attempt to reduce dissonance. That then, and only then, does real change occur. Luckily, I just have this adorable blog and not a tenure track at a school in Boston dependent on whether my theory is true.

Now if we could just get those men who sit around watching football during a family gathering, while everyone around them is putting out food and cleaning, to feel LESS GUILTY about what they are doing, maybe they’ll feel better about themselves and actually get up and help. Sorry, my anti-sarcasm minion is away for the weekend.

Oh, what the hell. Here’s a diagram:

This is a HORRIBLE fucking diagram.

Categories: Uncategorized

9 replies »

  1. What if acceptance never comes? For me the peaceful approach feels like the non-apology everyone’s talking about. Like I can just identify all the ways I’m not meeting my own standards, tell myself it’s ok, relax a little, and accept it whether or not I change. I never buy any of it, that’s my problem. If I buy pants that fit I still notice my flabby abdomen, which makes me remember that I don’t exercise, which reminds me that I eat a lot of starch and cheese and sugar, which I feel bad about, so I reach for more and then I need bigger pants. This is my pattern. It’s 3 pm and I’ve done nothing all day and I could accept that, but I wouldn’t mean it. Maybe I should make a chart.

    • there;s a good chance that if accepting where you’re at doesn’t work, then you should implement a change in behavior. so, you could try that. i have just never instituted a changed behavior without having a gentler approach to self first. but,that’s me. and also, i would add that this does not apply to dirty bathrooms. acceptance of those things NEVER feels good. lovins!

Talk to me, people!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s